The Irresistible Impulse Test

By Stephanie Lee

The Irresistible Impulse test made its debut in America in 1844 when a man named Abner Rodger stabbed and murdered a prison warden in the prison where he was being held.  His only defense was that he was insane during the actual stabbing.  However, the chief justice judging the trial was stated to the jury:

“If then it is proved, to the satisfaction of the jury, that the mind of the accused was in a diseased and unsound state, the question will be, whether the disease existed to so high a degree, that for the time being it overwhelmed the reason, conscience, and judgement, and whether the prisoner…acted from an irresistible and incontrollable impulse.  If so, then the act was not the act of a voluntary agent, but the involuntary act of the body, without the concurrence of a mind directing it.” (Commonwealth v. Rodgers, 1844, p. 502)

The Chief Justice Shaw elaborated by concluding his statement being letting the jury know that if this is the case that Rodger would not be held responsible for his criminal acts. The jury found Rodgers not guilty by reason of insanity.  This test that acquitted Rodgers of his crime involved knowing right from wrong but being unable to stop from committing the “wrong” act.  In 1897, The Supreme Court adopted the Irresistible Impulse test and thus rejectingthe M’Naghten Rule out completely(Garrison, 1998).

However, there there was a problem with the Irresistible Impulse Test: it failed to differentiate between the impulse that cannot be resisted and the impulse that was not resisted.  There was a still a remnant of vagueness due to being unable to truly know what a person committing the act is really thinking in the moment.  Despite this, the test has still remained in the United States court system and has been used (Garrison, 1998).

A well-known case in which this irresistible Impulse test was used was the case of Lorena Bobbitt in 1994 where she was found not guilty when her defense used the Irresistible Impulse.

Bobbitt was tried because she cut off her husband’s penis one night after he returned home drunk from a party and had then raped her (Bell, 2010).  This trial highly publicized the Irresistible Impulse Test due to the enormous amount of publicity this case had received during its time.

References:

alyankovich (2008). Lorena bobbit trial day one. Retrieved from:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3XnuPOk144c

Commonwealth v. Rodgers, 7 Metcalf 500 (Mass. 1844)

Garrison, A. H. (1998). The history of the M’Naghten insanity defense and the use of posttraumatic stress disorder as a basis of insanity. American Journal of Forensic Psychology, 16, 39-88.

Bell, R. (2010). Crimes below the belt: penile removal and castration. Retrieved from:http://www.trutv.com/library/crime/criminal_mind/sexual_assault/severed_penis/index.html

6 Responses to “The Irresistible Impulse Test”

  1. Stuffy McPlumnuckets says:

    I appreciate the history lesson, however your actual understanding of the material is lacking. You might also want to clean up the formatting and the many grammatical errors.

  2. Bud Skene says:

    Hey just wanted to give you a quick heads up and let you know a few of the images aren’t loading properly. I’m not sure why but I think its a linking issue. I’ve tried it in two different internet browsers and both show the same outcome.

  3. bogner shop says:

    bogner shop

    5. Haagen Dazs Ice Cream Gemüse

  4. John Adams says:

    this is soooooo stupid i hate all of you!

  5. *I find the Irresistible Impulse THEORY to be rather fascinating etc….

  6. I find the Irresistible Impulse to be rather fascinating especially the statement by Chief Justice Shaw talking about the dis-connect between the body απϑ the mind during the commission of the act.

    Now, is it the intense mental απϑ psychological pressure leading up to the act that causes this said dis-connect..?

    I guess I can comfortably say that there’s a beast in-side all of us that is barely re-strained by societal conditioning which when push comes to shove rears it head απϑ strikes, leaving us be-fuddled in its wake….

Leave a Reply